Measurement of Flexural Rigidity of Plywood-Webbed Box

SURE: Shizuoka University REpository
http://ir.lib.shizuoka.ac.jp/
Title
Author(s)
Citation
Issue Date
URL
Measurement of Flexural Rigidity of Plywood-Webbed BoxBeams by Vibration Method
Sobue, Nobuo; Ikeda, Kiyohiko; Arima, Takanori
木材学会誌. 34(6), p. 543-546
1988-06
http://hdl.handle.net/10297/4596
Version
publisher
Rights
Copyright © 日本木材学会
This document is downloaded at: 2015-02-01T00:27:41Z
5
4
3
[
Mo
kuEat
'Gakkal
s
hz
- vol
･
3
4,No･
6
,p･
5
4
3
5
4
6(
1
9
8
8
)
]
Me
as
弧T
e
me
n息ofF且
e
x弧T
a
且温i
gi
誠紙yof
鮎鮎e
d迅蝿 Be
ams触yVi
bT
a息
i
omM如hod*
l
mywoo姐-We
Nobuo SoBUE*2
,Ki
yohi
koIKEDA*3andTaka
nor
iARI
MA*4
振動法による合板ウェブボックスビームの曲げ剛性の測定 *
1
祖父江信夫喪
2
,池田潔彦 *
3
,有馬孝穏 *4
振動試験による合板ウェブ･ボックスビームの曲げ剛性 (
EI
)の測定法を検討した｡
試験体は総数 3
0体で,同一製造マニュアルに従って 6社で製造された｡両端を単純支持した栄
をゴム‥ ンマで打撃し,支持点に加わる振動の反力の波形から梁の固有振動数を求めた｡
ボックスピ- ムを均質梁とみなして振動理論を適用した場合およびボックスビームの構造の不
均一性を考慮して伝達マトリクス法を適用した場合について検討したo計算結果に両者の差は認
5%過小評価した｡
められず, 静的曲げ試験による EIに比べていずれも平均値で約 1
振動試験によって,梁の重量と固有振動数から静的曲げ剛性を推定するモデル式を誘導した｡
Thene
xur
alr
i
g
i
di
t
y(
EI)ofpl
ywoo we
bbe
dbox
be
a
mse
s
t
i
ma
t
edf
r
om mi
ni
mum i
nf
or
ma
t
i
on
●
i
nar
nanuf
T
a
c
t
ur
l
ngPr
oc
e
s
sWasi
nve
s
t
i
ga
t
e
d.
Thi
r
t
ys
i
mpl
e
s
uppor
t
e
dbox
be
amswe
r
et
a
ppe
dwi
t
haha
mme
r
,a
ndt
her
e
s
ona
nc
ef
r
e
que
nc
i
e
s
we
r
eme
a
s
ur
e
df
r
om t
hef
T
r
e
evi
br
a
t
i
onsoft
hebe
a
ms
.
か
Theel
e
me
nt
ar
y
Vi
br
a
t
i
ont
he
or
yofuni
f
or
m be
a
msandat
r
a
ns
f
e
r
ma
t
r
i
xme
t
hodf
orvi
br
a
t
i
on
pr
obl
e
mswe
r
eus
e
dt
oe
s
t
i
ma
t
et
heEIoft
hebe
a
ms
.Ther
e
s
ul
t
swe
r
ec
ompa
r
e
dw
it
ht
hos
eb
■
ly
s
t
at
i
c
bendi
n
gt
e
s
t
s
.Bot
hEIe
s
t
i
mat
e
sbyt
hee
l
e
me
nt
a
rvi
br
a
t
i
ont
he
or
yandbyt
het
r
a
ns
f
e ma
t
r
i
x
5% t
hant
ha
tbyt
hes
t
a
t
i
c
be
ndi
ngt
e
s
t
s
.
me
t
hodwe
r
es
ma
l
l
e
rbyana
ve
r
a
ge1
A pr
e
di
c
t
i
onf
わr
mul
aofEIbys
t
a
t
i
ct
e
s
t
sc
a
l
c
ul
a
t
e
df
r
om vi
br
a
t
i
ont
e
s
t
swa
sobt
ai
ne
d.
y
ト
Ke
ywo
r
･
ds:boxbe
am,me
xur
a
lr
i
idi
g
t
y,vi
br
a
t
i
onme
t
hod･
us
eha
sbe
e
nl
a
i
df
orbot
ht
e
c
hni
c
alandf
unda
me
nt
a
l
1
.I
NTRODUCTI
ON
The s
hor
t
ageofl
ar
gかS
i
z
et
i
mbe
r
sand i
mpr
ove
as
pe
c
t
s
･Thi
s dat
a ha
st
he pot
e
nt
i
a
lt
os
uppl
y
de
s
i
gne
dbe
a
msofl
a柑eS
i
z
e
.
me
nt
si
ngl
ui
ngt
e
c
hni
que
sha
v
epr
omot
e
dde
ve
l
op
Thi
swor
ka
i
mst
ode
t
e
r
mi
net
hef
e
as
i
bi
l
i
t
yofa
mentofc
ompos
i
t
ebea
msf
ors
t
r
uc
t
ur
a
lme
mbe
r
s
･I
n
ibr
v
a
t
i
ont
e
c
hni
quef
わre
s
t
i
ma
t
l
ngt
hene
xur
a
lr
igi
d-
he ut
i
l
l
i
z
a
t
i
on ofpl
ywood･
we
bbe
d box
J
apan, t
EI)ofpl
ywoodweb
be
d box･
be
a
msf
r
om t
he
i
t
y(
mi
ni
mum i
nf
or
ma
t
i
onwhi
c
hca
nbeobt
ai
ne
de
a
s
i
l
y
-
-
叫 butt
hebas
i
sf
brt
he
i
r
beamsi
snotpopul
aratpr
e
s
e
i
namanuf
a
c
t
ur
i
ngpr
oc
e
s
s;na
me
l
y,r
e
s
ona
nc
ef
r
e
･
Recei
v
e
dNov
e
mbe
r1
6,1
987
和
之名古屋大学贋学部 Fac
ul
t
y of Agr
i
c
ul
t
ur
e
,
Nagoy
aUni
ve
r
s
l
t
y,Chi
kus
a
ku,Na
goya46
4
*3 静岡県林業試験場 Shi
z
uoka Pr
e
f
e
c
t
ur
al For
es
t
r
yExpe
r
i
me
ntSt
a
t
i
on,Ne
ga
t
a Hama
ki
t
a43
4
*4 東京大学農学部
Fa
c
ul
t
y or Agr
i
c
ul
t
ur
e
,The
ku,Tokyo 11
3
Uni
ve
r
s
l
t
yOrTokyo,Bunkyo81
i
g
ht
,anddi
me
ns
i
onsorabe
a
m･
que
nc
y,we
Thi
swor
kwaspr
opos
e
dbe
ca
us
et
hede
s
i
gns
i
z
eor
woode
nbe
amsus
ual
l
yi
sc
ont
r
ol
l
edbyt
he
i
rs
t
i
f
f
ne
s
s
-
whi
c
hi
sapr
a
c
t
i
c
a
lde
s
i
gnpa
r
a
me
t
e
ri
nt
hede
s
i
g
nof
woode
ns
t
r
uc
t
ur
esa
ndbe
c
a
us
eavi
br
a
t
i
ont
e
c
hni
que
woul
dpr
ovi
deas
i
mpl
ede
vi
c
et
os
e
r
v
eapr
a
c
t
i
c
a
lu
s
e
Nobu
oSoBUE,Ki
y
ohi
koI
KEDAandTak
a
no
r
iARI
MA
5
44
[
Moku
z
aiGakk
aL
'
s
hE
.
EII 4･
l3･
fr
2･
W/
7
r
2
i
nf
T
a
c
t
or
i
e
s
.
(I
)
whe
r
eH sl
eng
t
h ora be
am,〟 i
st
her
e
s
onanc
e
2
.mATERI
ALANDMETHOI
)
S
f
r
equency,and w i
st
hewei
h toft
g
hebe
a
m･
2
.
1 Pl
ywo
odwe
bbe
dbo
xbe
ams
De
t
ai
l
sorbe
am c
ons
t
r
u
c
t
i
ona
r
es
howni
nFi
gur
e
2.
3.
2 Tr
ans
fe
r
mat
r
i
xmet
hod2)
I
.He
mFi
rorSpr
uc
e
Pi
ne
Fi
r2"by 4" (
nomi
nal
l
i
ne
arc
ombi
na
t
i
onoft
woki
ndsore
l
e
me
nt
s
,S
pr
l
ng
el
e
ment
sandma
s
se
l
e
me
nt
s
.
F
l
a
n
g
e(
2
'
'
b
y4F)
' *
St
i
f
f
n
e
r
(
2
〝b
y4′
′
)
*
A boxbe
a
m wascons
i
de
r
e
dasabe
am ma
deora
TF] andt
hepoi
ntma
t
r
i
xlTp
]of
Thef
i
e
l
dmat
r
i
xl
e
a
che
l
e
me
ntar
ee
xpr
e
s
s
e
dasf
ol
l
ows;
1I 1
2
/(
2EI)l3
/(
6EI)
[㌫ ]
=
01
00
I
/
EI
1
00
0
/
(
2EI)
/
l2
(
2)
1
1 0 0 0
3
6
4
0
and [㌫
〕n
i
t:
mm
Fi
g.1
.Cons
t
r
uc
t
i
on or pl
ywoodwebbed box
be
ams
.
Nomi
na
li
nc
hs
i
z
e
sofme
mbe
r
s
.
*
0
]
=
1 0 0
0 0 10
(
3)
Ma
7
20 0 1 ,r
e
s
pe
c
t
i
ve
l
y,
smas
s
,a
nda i
sci
r
cul
arf
r
e
que
nc
y.
wher
eM i
Thet
r
ans
f
e
rma
t
r
i
xofane
ir
m
ebe
a
ml
N]i
sgi
v
en
bymul
t
i
pl
yi
ngt
hef
T
l
e
l
dma
t
r
i
xandt
hepoi
ntma
t
r
i
x
l
nt
ur
n,
i
nc
hs
i
z
e
)No･
2g
r
a
del
umbe
rwasus
e
df
わrmangea
nd
s
t
i
恥e
rme
mbe
r
s
･
No.1gr
adepl
y
wood,1
2mm t
hi
c
k
,wa
sus
e
df
T
orwe
bme
mbe
r
s
.
f
orc
ons
t
r
uc
t
i
onus
e
●
We
bme
mbe
r
swe
r
eJ
oi
ne
dwi
t
hma
ngeands
t
i
恥e
r
●
me
mbe
r
sby an a
qu
e
ousvl
nyトpol
y
me
rs
ol
ut
i
on
-
yl
β
l
[
Tp
n
][
TF
n
][
Tp
n
_
L
][TF
n
_L
]･
･
･
[Tp
l
][
TF
l
]
Ml
￠1
(
4)
-
be
t
we
e
ns
t
i
f
f
ne
rme
mbe
r
sa
ndma
ng
eme
mber
swe
r
e
ma
dewi
t
hCN9
0nai
l
s
.
Thi
r
t
ybox
be
a
mswe
r
ef
a
br
i
c
at
e
da
ts
i
xf
a
c
t
or
i
e
s;
name
l
y,r
l
V
ebe
a
msa
te
a
c
hf
a
c
t
or
y,a
c
c
or
di
ngt
ot
he
s
a
mepr
oc
e
s
s
i
ngf
or
mul
a.
2
.
2 Me
t
hods
EIwasme
as
ur
e
dbybot
hs
t
a
t
i
candvi
br
a
t
i
ont
es
t
s
.
e
l
γユ
i
s
oc
i
ana
t
eadhe
s
i
veandCN50nai
l
s
,andt
hej
oi
nt
s
-[
〃]
叫
(
5)
Ql
whe
r
e[
N]
,y,C
,M,a
nd Q ar
e(
4 × 4)mat
r
i
x,
de
f
わr
mat
i
on,
s
l
opeofbe
a
m,
mome
nt
,
ands
he
a
rf
or
c
e,
●
r
e
s
pec
t
i
ve
l
y.Thes
ubs
c
r
l
pt
S1and〟a
r
et
hepos
i
t
i
on
numbe
r
sort
het
woe
ndsort
hebe
am.
Thef
or
me
rwe
r
ema
dewi
t
hat
wopoi
ntl
oa
di
nga
t
The
n,Equa
t
i
on 5wa
ss
ol
ve
df
ort
hebounda
r
y
one
t
hi
r
dors
panl
e
ngt
h･Thel
a
t
t
e
rwe
r
ema
debyt
he
c
ondi
t
i
onofas
i
mpl
e
s
uppor
t
e
dbe
am ,
Iname
l
y,
ynyl
=OandMn-M1
-0.
f
r
e
evi
b
r
a
t
i
onofs
i
mpl
e
S
uppor
t
e
dbe
a
mswi
t
hs
pa
n
l
e
ng
t
hsor36
0c
m･Spe
c
i
me
nswe
r
et
a
ppe
d wi
t
ha
r
ubbe
rha
mme
ra
tt
he
i
rmi
dpol
nt
S
,a
ndt
hevi
br
a
t
i
onswe
r
ed
e
t
e
c
t
e
dbyal
oa
dc
e
l
lwhi
c
hwasi
ns
t
al
l
e
d
asoneoft
hes
uppor
tbl
oc
ks
.Ther
e
s
onanc
ef
T
r
e
-
que
n
c
ywa
sme
as
ur
e
dbyaFa
s
tFour
i
e
rTr
ans
f
わr
ma
-
Thea
c
c
ur
a
c
yoft
hes
ol
ut
i
onde
e ndsont
p
henum
be
rore
l
e
me
nt
sc
ons
i
de
r
e
d.I
twase
xa
mi
ne
d asa
-
homog
ene
ousr
e
c
t
a
ng
ul
a
rbe
am.Thedi
f
f
e
r
en
c
eofEI
be
t
we
e
n t
he t
r
ans
f
e
r
一
ma
t
r
i
x me
t
hod and t
he
r
･
t
i
onSpe
c
t
r
u
m Ar
l
al
yz
e
e
l
e
ment
a
r
y
vi
br
at
i
ont
he
or
yde
c
r
e
as
edwi
t
hi
nc
r
e
as
e
s
i
nt
henumbe
rore
l
e
me
nt
s
.I
nourwor
kt
henumbe
r
2
･
3 Cal
c
ul
at
i
o
no
fJZ
e
xur
alr
i
gi
di
t
y
ofe
l
e
me
nt
swe
r
e6
5.Thedi
f
f
e
r
e
nc
ewasa
bout5x
2
･
3
･
1 El
e
me
nt
ar
yt
he
o
r
yo
fv
i
b
r
at
i
onl)
1
0-4 %.
TheEIofas
i
mpl
e
s
uppor
t
e
duni
f
br
mbe
am byt
he
e
l
e
me
nt
a
r
y
v
i
br
a
t
i
ont
he
or
yl
Sgl
Ve
nby
vol
･3
4,No･6
,1
98
8
] Fl
e
xu
r
a
lRi
gi
di
t
yMe
a
s
ur
e
me
ntorPl
ywoodWe
bbe
dBox
Be
a
msbyVi
br
a
t
i
onMe
t
h
od 5
4
5
Thee
f
f
e
c
toft
hede
ns
l
t
yOfwe
bme
mbe
r
sa
l
s
owa
s
3.RESULTSANI
)DI
SCUSSI
ONS
3
･
I
Appl
i
c
at
l
ono
ft
hee
l
e
menl
ay
yv
i
br
at
E
'
ont
he
or
y
AnEJobt
ai
ne
dbys
t
at
i
c
be
ndi
ngt
e
s
t
s(
EI
s)i
snot
t
hepur
eEIofabox
be
am be
c
aus
ei
nabe
am whos
e
i
nve
s
t
i
gat
e
dwi
t
hr
e
s
pe
c
tt
ot
her
ang
e什om β=0
･
5t
o
0.
7g/
cm3
.Noi
nnue
nc
ee
xi
s
t
e
de
i
t
he
r
.
3
･
3 Theot
he
yc
aus
e
sa
j
fe
c
l
i
n
gEIe
s
t
i
mat
i
on
Ar
ot
a
t
or
yI
ne
r
t
i
aofbeamsa
f
f
e
c
t
sar
es
ona
nc
e
hei
ghti
sl
a
r
gef
わraboxbe
am t
hei
nnue
nc
eort
he
f
r
eque
nc
y.
3
)Thi
se
f
f
e
c
t
,whe
nt
hes
t
i
f
f
ne
rme
mbe
r
s
s
heardef
or
mat
i
onoft
hebe
am c
annotbei
gnor
ed･
we
r
edi
s
r
e
gar
dedi
nt
hec
al
cul
at
i
on,wase
s
t
i
mat
e
dt
o
bea
bout0
.
5%.Thi
sf
a
c
t
oral
s
owasmi
nori
n EI
●
es
t
l
mat
l
On.
Howe
ve
r
,t
hi
sappar
e
ntval
uei
sus
edcur
r
ent
l
yasa
pr
act
i
cali
ndi
c
at
orort
he me
chani
calpr
ope
r
t
y or
compos
i
t
ebeams
.Ourgoali
s
,t
he
r
ef
わr
e,howwec
an
sb
yvi
br
at
i
ont
e
c
hni
ques
･
es
t
i
mat
et
heEI
Thes
he
a
rde
f
or
mat
i
onoft
hi
c
kbe
a
msa
f
f
e
c
t
st
he
i
r
appa
r
entde
ne
c
t
i
on.Thet
ot
a
lde
ne
c
t
i
onorabe
am
Ther
e
l
at
i
ons
hi
p be
t
we
en EI by s
t
at
i
ct
e
s
t
sand
EI
v)was
t
hatby t
heel
e
me
nt
a
r
yvi
br
a
t
i
on t
heor
y(
i
nves
t
l
gat
ed.
●
TheEI
vt
o EI
sr
a
t
i
o ave
r
a
g
ed0.
8
49w
it
has
t
anvwass
mal
l
e
rby1
5%
dar
dde
vi
at
i
onofO･
0821TheEI
(
y)i
st
hes
um oft
hede
ne
c
t
i
onbyamome
nt(
yM)an
d
t
ha
tbyas
he
a
rf
or
c
e(
yQ)
.
y=yM+
yQ=yM(I+C
)
(
6)
They
Qt
Oy
Mr
at
i
o(
C)i
sg
ive
nby4)
t
han t
he EIs･ Why doe
ss
uc
h a di
f
f
er
enc
ee
xi
s
t
be
t
we
ent
het
wome
t
hods?
(
7)
C
-(
i)
i
･
KL
･
KF
･
(
i)
2
whe
r
eK
Li
sal
oadf
a
c
t
or
,KFi
sadi
me
ns
i
onl
e
s
ss
he
a
r
Cons
i
der
i
ngt
her
ol
eorea
chel
e
me
nti
nabe
am,
t
he
f
a
c
t
or
,(
E/G)
ii
st
hee
qui
va
lentE t
oG r
a
t
i
oofa
s
t
i
nt
ne
rme
mbe
r
sc
ont
r
i
but
enotonl
y ass
t
r
uc
t
ur
a
l
member
s butal
s
o asa c
onc
ent
r
at
ed mas
swhi
c
h
beam,and h/
Ii
st
hehe
i
g
ht
t
ol
e
ng
t
hr
at
i
o.
di
i ni
m
s
hest
her
es
onanc
ef
r
e
quencyofabe
am.I
nt
he
EI
vand EI
s be
c
aus
et
he
r
ei
sa di
f
f
e
r
e
nc
ei
nt
he
el
eme
nt
a
r
yvi
br
at
i
ont
he
or
y,t
hel
at
t
ere
f
f
e
c
ti
sa
ve
r
manne
rorl
oa
di
ng;na
me
l
y,at
wopol
ntl
oa
di
ngf
わr
-
,KL4)af
f
e
c
t
st
hedi
f
f
e
r
enc
ebe
t
we
e
n
Oft
he
s
ef
a
c
t
or
s
agedbydi
s
t
r
i
but
i
ngt
hema
s
soft
hes
t
i
f
f
ne
rme
mbe
r
s
s
t
at
i
ct
es
t
sa
ndas
i
nus
oi
dal
l
ydi
s
t
r
i
but
e
dl
oa
di
ngf
or
uni
丘)
r
ml
yove
rt
hee
nt
i
r
el
eng
t
hort
hebeam.Thi
s
vi
br
a
t
i
ont
e
s
t
s
.The
r
e
f
わr
e
,g L=
9.
3
9f
わrs
t
at
i
ct
es
t
s
,
i ghtbeoneort
m
hec
aus
eoft
hee
r
r
ori
n EIes
t
i
ma
-
a
ndだ L = 9.
87f
わrvi
br
a
t
i
ont
e
s
t
s
.Thi
sme
anst
ha
t
he f
ol
l
owi
ng t
r
anS
f
T
e
r
mat
r
i
x
t
i
ons
. Ther
ef
or
e, t
met
hod was us
e
dt
o de
t
e
r
mi
ne t
he e
f
hc
t
soft
he
t
hev
i
br
a
t
i
ont
e
s
ti
nduc
e
sani
nc
r
e
as
eorg L b
ya
bout
cons
t
i
t
ut
i
onof
.
abe
a
m onEIes
t
i
mat
i
ons
.
t
.Fi
na
l
l
y,t
hevi
br
a
t
i
on
5渇mor
et
ha
nt
hes
t
a
t
i
ct
e
s
t
es
te
s
t
i
ma
t
e
st
hegJ 1
.
2渇 l
e
s
st
handoe
st
hes
t
a
t
i
c
3.
2Appl
i
cat
l
'
ono
ft
het
r
ans
fe
r
mat
r
i
x me
t
hod
t
e
s
t
.
(I)The
r
ei
snos
l
i
pbe
t
we
enwe
bandmang
eme
mbe
r
s
･
The
r
es
t
i
l
lexi
s
t
sadi
f
f
e
r
e
nc
eofEIby1
3t
o1
4渇
be
t
we
ent
hes
t
at
i
ct
e
s
t
sandvi
br
a
t
i
ont
e
s
t
s
.Thec
aus
e
(
2)Thes
t
i
f
f
ne
rme
mber
sal
s
owor
kasaconc
e
nt
r
a
t
e
d
oft
hi
sdi
f
r
e
r
e
nc
ei
snotcl
earatt
hi
st
i
me,andf
ur
t
he
r
mas
s
.(3)Thedens
i
t
yofnangeands
t
i
f
F
nerme
mbe
r
s
i
nve
s
t
l
ga
t
i
oni
snotpl
a
nne
dbe
c
aus
eourf
i
nalt
a
r
g
e
t
i
s0.
5g/
cm3
.(
4)Themas
soft
henai
l
si
st
akeni
nt
o
i
sonl
yhow t
oe
s
t
i
ma
t
et
heEIf
r
om t
h
emi
ni
mum
cons
i
der
at
i
on,butt
hatort
hegl
uei
sdi
s
r
ega
r
ded･
i
nf
わr
ma
t
i
ononbea
mswhi
c
hi
sobt
ai
ne
deas
i
l
yi
nt
he
Thef
わl
l
owi
ngas
s
umpt
l
OnSWe
r
ei
mpos
e
d:
Thedi
f
托r
enc
eofEIbe
t
we
ent
her
es
ul
t
sby t
he
manuf
ac
t
ur
i
ngPr
OC
eS
S
･
el
ement
a
r
yvi
br
at
i
on t
he
or
y and by t
he t
r
a
ns
f
e
r
mat
r
i
xme
t
hodwasl
es
st
han0.
1%.Thi
sme
anst
hat
3
.
4Pr
e
di
ct
i
onfor
mul
ao
f EI
sfr
o
mv
i
br
at
i
o
nt
e
s
t
s
t
he c
onc
ent
r
a
t
ed mas
sofs
t
i
f
f
nerme
mber
shasno
Fi
gur
e2.Thes
t
a
t
i
s
t
i
c
alr
es
ul
t
sha
v
es
hownt
ha
tEI
v
/
s
l
gni
r
l
Cante
f
f
e
c
tont
hec
al
c
ul
a
t
i
onoft
heEIofa
boxbeam.
EI
si
sO･
8
490na
ve
r
a
g
eandt
ha
ti
t
ss
t
anda
r
dde
v
i
a
t
i
oni
s0.
08
2.
●
Ac
c
or
di
ngl
y,t
hef
bl
l
owl
nge
qua
t
i
onwi
l
lpr
edi
c
-
Thee
f
f
e
ctoft
hedens
i
t
i
e
soft
hemang
eands
t
i
f
f
ne
r
membe
r
swasi
nv
e
s
t
l
gat
eWi
t
hr
es
pec
tt
ot
her
ange
f
r
om p-0.
40t
oO･
60g/c
m3c
ons
i
de
r
i
ngt
hec
as
eof
HemFi
rand S
pFl
umbe
r
.Dens
l
t
yhadnoi
nnuenCe.
Ther
e
l
at
i
ons
hi
pbe
t
we
e
nEI
san
dEI
vi
ss
howni
n
-
EI
sf
r
om Et
v:
1
.
1
8EI
v
EI
s-
(
8
､
Howe
ve
r
,t
hi
se
qua
t
i
onove
r
e
s
t
i
ma
t
e
st
heEIv;
oft
hepl
ot
sbe
l
ow t
hi
spr
e
di
c
t
i
onl
i
ne･Thi
so
ve
l
[
Mo
ku
z
alGakkaI
'
s
hE
'
NobuoS
oB
UE,Ki
y
ohi
k
oI
KEDA a
ndTa
ka
no
r
iARI
MA
546
l S
i
nnue
nc
eont
hec
a
l
c
ul
a
t
i
onofEI
.
Ot
he
rf
a
c
t
or
s af
f
e
c
t
l
ng EI c
al
c
ul
a
t
i
ons wer
e
)
⊥＼
ns
i
t
i
e
s ofs
t
i
r
F
ne
r and web
e
xami
ne
d;na
me
l
y,de
I
me
mbe
r
s
,ar
ot
a
t
or
yI
ne
r
t
i
a,andas
he
ardef
わr
mat
i
on,
山
X
a
^q ^ 1!
P!
B!
Lf
eJn
t
hos
ebys
t
a
t
i
cbe
ndi
ngt
e
s
t
s
･
Ther
e
s
ul
toft
het
r
ans
f
e
r
一
ma
t
r
i
xme
t
hod pr
oved
t
hatt
hec
onc
e
nt
r
a
t
e
dma
s
sofs
t
i
f
f
ne
rme
mbe
r
shadno
(
.
･
L
uU･
61.
,
OtX
Ie
■
1Sa}U!
ga
ves
mal
l
e
rval
ue
sOFEIb
y1
5% Ona
ve
r
ag
et
han
に
0.
4
0.
4
0
.
6
0.
8
1
.
0
1
.
2
,E/
V(
xlO9k
g･
c
m1-)
F
I
e
x
u
r
a
l
r
i
g
i
d
i
t
yb
yv
i
b
r
a
t
i
o
nt
e
s
t
Fi
g.
2
.Pr
e
di
c
t
i
on f
or
mul
a ofEI f
r
om vi
br
a
t
i
on
t
e
s
t
s
.
p i
s9
5%l
owe
rc
onf
i
de
nc
el
i
mi
tofEI
svs
Not
e: EI
EIvl
i
ne
.
butt
he
ywe
r
emi
norf
a
c
t
or
s
･
A pr
e
di
c
t
i
onf
or
mul
a(
EI
,) o
fEI
sf
r
om EI
v was
a
r
r
i
ve
dati
nEquat
i
on9
･
I
nc
onc
l
us
i
on,t
hepr
opos
e
dvi
br
a
t
i
onme
t
hodi
sa
f
e
a
s
i
bl
e pr
a
c
t
i
c
alway f
or pr
e
di
c
t
i
ng t
he EI of
I
pl
ywoodwe
bbe
dbox
be
a
ms
.
Ac
knowl
e
d
ge
me
nt
t
i
ma
t
i
on i
snota
c
c
e
pt
a
bl
ef
r
om t
hevi
e
wpoi
ntOf
s
t
r
u
c
t
u
r
a
lde
s
i
gnbe
c
aus
ei
te
s
t
i
ma
t
e
st
hede
ne
c
t
i
onof
abe
a
ma
sbe
i
ngl
e
s
st
ha
nt
hea
c
t
ua
lde
ne
c
t
i
on.
The
n,t
hel
owe
rc
onf
i
de
nc
el
i
mi
tof9
5渇 wa
sus
ed
a
sa
ppr
opr
i
a
t
et
Or
e
du
c
et
hea
c
c
e
pt
a
bl
er
i
s
kl
e
ve
l
,
EIp-I
.
0
2EIv
(
9)
Thi
spr
e
di
c
t
i
onl
i
neal
s
oi
ss
howni
nFi
g
ur
e2.
4
.
CONCLUS
I
ON
A vi
br
a
t
i
on me
t
hod f
orme
a
s
ur
i
ng t
he EI of
pl
y
woodwe
bbe
dbox
be
amswa
si
nv
e
s
t
i
g
a
t
e
d.
Thee
l
e
me
nt
a
rvi
br
a
t
i
ont
he
or
yofuni
f
or
m be
a
ms
y
Wet
hankt
heJapan2"by
4′
′HomeBui
l
de
r
sAs
s
oc
i
a
t
i
on f
わrpr
omot
i
ng t
hi
s
r
e
s
e
a
r
c
h.
REFERENCES
1
)Ti
mi
s
he
nko,
S∴ "Vi
br
at
i
on Pr
obl
ems in
●
Engl
ne
e
r
l
ng"
,TokyoTos
ho,1
978,p.
297.
,D.
J
∴"
Mat
r
i
xComput
e
rMe
t
hodsor
2)Ha
t
t
e
r
Vi
br
a
t
i
on Anal
ys
i
s
"
,Br
a
i
n Tos
ho Shuppan,
1
97
7,p.Ill-1
22.
3)Ti
mos
he
nko, S∴ "Vi
br
a
t
i
on Pr
obl
ems i
n.
Engl
ne
e
r
l
ng"
,Tok
yoTos
ho,1
978,p.3
06.
.･
.Ho
b Roj
z
.We
r
ks
E
.
,27(
7)
,25
3
4)Ehl
be
c
k,J
-
26日 1
96
9)
.

Download Report