Spectroscopic search for Na in the exosphere of 55 Cancri e

Tentative detection
of sodium and ionized
calcium from the
exoplanet 55 Cancri e
Andrew Ridden-Harper
I. A. G. Snellen, C. U. Keller, R. J. de
Kok, E. Di Gloria, H. J. Hoeijmakers, M.
Brogi, M. Fridlund, B. L. A. Vermeersen,
W. van Westrenen, A. van den Berg
Andrew Ridden-Harper, Groningen PEPSci meeting 15/1/2016
What do we already know?
Mass
Radius
8 Earth masses
2 Earth radii
Density: 4 g cm-3
Two ideas:
• Normal oxygen-rich silicate & iron
composition
→ Hydrogen or water atmosphere
Gillon et al. 2012
• Unusual carbon-rich
composition
→ no atmosphere
(host star is carbon rich)
Madhusudhan et al. 2012
Very high temperature


Orbits very close to host star

experience intense radiation

possible tidal heating
Mercury
55 Cancri e
Orbital distance (AU)
0.387
0.016
Equilibrium temp (K)
~435
~1900
Observed temperatures between 1300 and 2800 K

volcanic activity?

circumstellar/circumplanetary disk?
(Demory et al. 2015)
Exosphere of Mercury from
sputtering

Impact of radiation & energetic particles from
Sun

Ejects atoms from surface

Creates exosphere of
surface material
Na exosphere of Mercury observed by
MESSENGER (NASA)
Extend to exoplanets

Close-in rocky exoplanets hotter than Mercury

More extreme exosphere that might be detected?
Simulated Na exosphere of CoRoT-7b Mura et al. 2011

Guenther et al. 2011 observed CoRoT-7b


Non-detection and upper limits
55 Cnc 200 times brighter than CoRoT-7

Higher S/N so better chance of detection
55 Cancri e data

5 time series spectroscopic transit data sets:

1xUVES/VLT (8m, clouds)
(only for Na)

2xHARPS/ESO 3.6m (3.6m)

2xHARPS-N/TNG (3.68)
(for Na and Ca+)

Resolution R ~ 100000
Source:
http://www.aip.de/groups/opti/MUSE/
time
Planet’s changing radial velocity
wavelength
Image credit: Remco de Kok
Process to remove stellar
and telluric lines
 Divide
by median spectrum
time
 Remove
wavelength
structure with PCA
Very strong injected signal of 5%
(demonstration purposes only)
(Indicated regions are approximate)
Very strong injected signal of 5%
(demonstration purposes only)
(Indicated regions are approximate)
Shift to planet frame
(5% injected signal)
Shift to planet frame
(5% injected signal)
Sum
Shift to planet frame
(5% injected signal)
Sum
S/N = 16
~3.1𝜎𝜎 of Na
from average
~3.1𝜎𝜎 of Na
from average
Average Na
~4.8𝜎𝜎 Ca+ in only
HARPS A
~4.8𝜎𝜎 Ca+ in only
HARPS A
HARPS A zoom-in
~4.8𝜎𝜎 Ca+ in only
HARPS A
HARPS A zoom-in
Blue shift
Possible tail interpretations
Mura et al. 2011
Bourrier et al. 2015
Conclusions

Na: 3.1𝜎𝜎 in weighted average

Ca+: 4.8𝜎𝜎 in only one dataset

If detection of Ca+ is real, 55 Cancri e must be highly
variable

If confirmed, would be evidence against a hydrogen
or water atmosphere

Follow-up observations with UVES/VLT on the way
Andrew Ridden-Harper, Groningen PEPSci meeting 15/1/2016
Estimate of physical scale of
absorbing cloud

Radius of optically-thick spherical cloud that
would absorb the same as what is absorbed by 55
Cancri e


Na


Determine absorption by injecting artificial signal
early in analysis
Corresponds to an optically-thick Na cloud filling
Roche lobe
Ca+

Corresponds to optically-thick cloud of radius 5×
Roche lobe radius (possibly extended tail)
Faint trace of Ca+ signal
across spectra
55 Cancri e UVES data analysis
time
Stack the spectra in a matrix
wavelength
55 Cancri e UVES data analysis
time
Stack the spectra in a matrix
wavelength
Follow up observations

Two more transits with UVES/VLT


Time was allocated, now working on phase 2 details
Possibility of two more transits in next VLT semester

Monitor for possibility of variability